Do you agree that breastfeeding is not just tedious but challenging, especially when you have to pump because you need to be away from your baby? If you don’t pump frequently a manual breast pump will work for you.
The manual breast pump is cheaper than an electric breast pump, but it does the same job. If you are a stay-at-home mom and only pumps from time to time or rarely do, a manual breast pump is perfect.
If you are interested in this type of pump, this article is for you. Just stick because I am giving you the 5 Best Manual Breast Pump 2017 review.
- 1 5 Best Manual Breast Pump Review 2017
- 2 What Manual Breast Pump to Choose?
- 3 What Is Manual Breast Pump?
- 4 Do Manual Breast Pumps Work?
- 5 How To Use Manual Breast Pump Effectively?
- 6 Is Manual Breast Pump Better Than Electric?
- 7 How Manual Breast Pump Works?
- 8 Conclusion
5 Best Manual Breast Pump Review 2017
I understand that choosing the top manual breast pump can be challenging, considering the volume of brands available on the market today. So, to help you decide I am giving you a list of the top manual breast pump.
This list is a product of years of research. I’ve used the majority of these products and interviewed friends and acquaintances who used these manual breast pumps too about their experience.
These products have the most positive response from everyone of us. I know that you can’t wait any longer, so let’s get down to business.
|Medela Harmony Manual Breast Pump||2-Phase Expression technology. Portable. Quiet.||Expensive||$30||4.7/5||Click Here|
|Philips Avent Manual Comfort Breast Pump||Lightweight and Compact. Offers more comfortable position.||Poor design. Flange neck too short.||$26.99||4.5/5||Click Here|
|Lansinoh Manual Breast Pump||ComfortFit flanges. Ergonomic design. BPA-free.||Poor suction. Pumping takes time. Does not work for some.||$20.99||4.3/5||Click Here|
|Haakaa Silicone Breastfeeding Manual Breast Pump||Affordable. 100% Food Grade Silicone. No Assembly.||Poor Suction. Slow. Does not work for everyone.||$18.99||4.2/5||Click Here|
|Blue Moon Manual Silicone Breast Pump||Affordable. No assembly required. Portable.||Poor suction. Does not for work for some.||$13.95||4.2/5||Click Here|
1. Medela Harmony Manual Breast Pump Review
Medela is one of the most popular brand pumps worldwide. They have manual and electric breast pumps, so our list cannot be completed without including one from them.
Harmony from Medela is a single manual breast pump that is designed for occasional time away from the baby. This is the best hand pump for you if you want a lightweight, portable and discreet item.
This is very easy to use because this is equipped with a 2 Phase Expression technology with an ergonomic swivel handle that makes manual pumping comfortable. This is a great complement to a Medela double-electric breast pump and is compatible with PersonalFit breast shields too.
Nine out of 10 moms prefer Medela Harmony Manual Breast Pump over other manual pumps that is why it tops our list.
Aside from its lightweight design that makes it perfect for on-the-go pumping, it allows you to pump more milk in lesser time. Also, it doesn’t make any annoying sounds.
This pump is very easy to set up and clean because it has fewer parts.
However, if there is one thing that I don’t like about this product, perhaps it is its cost. This is a bit pricey compared to most manual pumps.
However, given its efficiency and quality, I can say that this is worth every penny. So, I highly recommend this product.
What’s In The Box
• Harmony Breastpump (1)
• 24 mm PersonalFit breastshield (1)
• 5 oz/150mL BPA-free breastmilk bottle with lid and stand (1)
• Valve (1)
• Membrane (1)
• Spare membranes (2)
2. Philips Avent Manual Comfort Breast Pump Review
Philips Avent is another great brand when it comes to manual pumps. It is more comfortable to use and efficiently help moms extract milk.
Philips Avent Comfort Manual Breast Pump is uniquely designed for a more relaxing and comfortable expressing position that promotes milk flow. Unlike other breast pumps that only work when you lean forward, this particular pump allows you to sit comfortably upright as you pump while its angled neck allows milk to flow naturally from your breast to the bottle.
It has a soft massage cushion with 5 textured petals intended to help stimulate milk flow. It mimics the baby’s natural suckling patterns so it makes expressing milk easy and more convenient.
It also comes with an ergonomic handle to make the process easier. In addition to this, it is lightweight, has a compact design for easy one-hand operation and comes with collection container that also works as a bottle.
For moms, this brand is a great item to try on because it is easy to work on. It has a few parts that are all washable in the dishwasher. It can be sterilized using a Philips Avent steam sterilizer or by boiling in the water for 5 minutes.
Overall, this product is a great item to try on. Its gel pad looked squishy and felt comfortable. It is also quiet and does not have any tubes, wires or hoses.
Also, its price is more than reasonable. It is not too expensive for its quality and performance.
Most of all, it performs better than what I expected. It requires very little effort to express large quantities of milk rapidly and its suction is great. It is not taxing on my hands.
However, just like other most items, this product also comes with its own set of flaws. While its suction is great, its design does not match Medela Harmony.
Its flange neck is so short, so you have to hold it close to your body. This can be annoying and hard to do while keeping suction. Due to this, you can’t also see the milk from your nipple, there is a tendency to waste your precious milk.
However, despite this problem, this product remains a great item. It works as it should. So, I highly recommend this.
• Breast pump – Polypropylene, BPA free
• Bottle – Polypropylene, BPA free
• Nipple – Silicone, BPA free
• No leaning forward
• Soft massage cushion for gentle stimulation
• Combines breast and bottle feeding
• Compact design
• Ergonomic shape
• Wide neck
What’s in the Box
• Breast pump body with handle (1)
• Standard size cushion (1)
• Natural bottle 4 oz (1)
• Extra soft newborn flow nipple (1)
• Sealing disc for milk storage (1)
• Breast pad sample packs (2 days pads and 2 night pads)
3. Lansinoh Manual Breast Pump Review
Lansinoh is among the leaders in breastfeeding products and accessories. They produce quality items specifically, manual breast pumps.
This pump is very easy to set up making it perfect for occasional use at home. It is lightweight, small and portable which is very handy and convenient, in case you have to bring this when traveling.
It only has 3-4 parts making it easy to assemble, clean and dry. Its size is also perfect for a diaper bag, making it very convenient to take with you anywhere you go.
For your comfort, it allows you to easily switch between two pumping modes: stimulation and expression that aids in let-down and maximizes pumping efficiency. It also includes an ergonomic easy-express handle that reduces fatigue.
It also comes with two ComfortFit flange sizes, standard (25mm) and large (30.5mm) for ideal suction and fit. In addition to this it has a wide neck bottle that makes milk transfer easier and compatible with the NaturalWave Nipple.
It is also equipped with a two-phase technology that assists with milk let-down for more efficient pumping.
Overall, this item is very efficient. In fact, I met some moms who find this better than electrical breast pumps when it comes to ease of use.
However, just like most products, there are some customers who were not happy with this. I heard from some friends that it took them too long to pump a small amount of milk. This didn’t work for them.
As for me, I have a great experience with this. It worked well for me. So, I still recommend this.
• Manufacturer #: 50520
• Product Weight:0.8 pounds
• Product Dimensions (in inches):7.8 x 7.6 x 4.1
4. Haakaa Silicone Breastfeeding Manual Breast Pump Review
Haakaa Silicone Manual Breast Pump is made from soft and comfortable 100% food grade silicone. It is very easy to use because you do not need to assemble it and it works immediately by just suctioning it to your breast.
It has no small parts and cord free making it very convenient for travelling. In addition to this, it works without charging or plugging in. It also fits into any handbag or diaper bag.
As for usage and maintenance, it requires little effort. You can sterilize it by using any steam sterilizing system or boiling water.
This pump is guaranteed to work, but you may need to adjust for a couple of times. To use this efficiently, you can put a warm flannel on top of your breast and gently massage it. Once the milk starts to flow, leave the pump to do its thing.
Overall, this is a great pump, except that it didn’t work for everyone. Some moms reported about its poor suction and slow speed. Others find it painful while only collecting a few drops.
Personally I also struggled at the beginning and I thought it won’t work for me. However, after trying for a few times, it eventually worked.
Haakaa Silicone Manual breast Pump is affordable and it works, it just takes time. So, yes, I still recommend this.
• Height: 5.7 inches
• Weight: 2.2 inches
• Flange Diameter: 3.4 inches
• Size: 4 oz
What’s in the box
5. Blue Moon Manual Silicone Breast Pump Review
The Blue Moon Manual Silicone Breast Pump has a somewhat similar design with Haakaa but it has ultra-flexible silicone. It is small, lightweight, portable, and needs no assembly making it one of the best on-the-go pumps for moms.
Design wise, if you don’t want cramming cords, noisy motors, plastic tubing and flanges stuffed on your diaper bag, this is the best manual pump for you.
It also includes a protective lid to keep dust and dirt away at the same time prevents milk residue from flowing onto other contents of your diaper bag. Please take note that this is not spill-proof.
This pump uses a dual-vulcanization process to produce one of the most flexible silicone pumps. It is also very easy to use. Just suction it to our opposite breast while nursing your baby.
The good thing about this particular pump is that you can use it even without electricity. This will be very helpful during long trips, camping and blackouts.
This product is also easy to keep and maintain. For cleaning, you can hand wash it with non-bleach based detergent or drop it into your dishwasher. It has a wide opening, so you can also clean it with a bottle cleaner.
This particular pump is strong enough to survive high temperature. Since it is made from food-grade silicone, it can withstand temperature up to 1.20° C.
After a number of uses, I can really say that this is a good product. It is very useful and effective.
However, it might need a few adjustments. It took a few tries for some moms, including me to finally make this work. Meanwhile, others claimed that it did not work for them at all.
It is normal for a good product to receive both positive and negative feedbacks. Users react differently to this item, so it is understandable that it works for the other and not for the rest.
However, as for me, it worked well. Although there are a few issues, it still helped me. So, I still recommend this.
• Dimensions: 6″H x 3.5″W x 2.5″D
• Weight: 2.6 ounces
• Capacity: 100 ml
• Dishwasher safe
• Do not clean using bleach-based detergent
• Not recommended for microwave use
What Manual Breast Pump to Choose?
These brands are effective in helping you express milk manually. I’ve used all of them and sought the opinions of my friends who also utilized the same products. I can say that while I have a satisfying experience with the majority of them, customers have different feedbacks about it.
For those new about manual pumps or if you feel that you still need to learn more about it, the next section will be helpful to you. It aims to help moms get familiar with manual pumps. So please continue reading.
What Is Manual Breast Pump?
A manual breast pump helps you extract milk for your newborn by hand.
It usually comes with a shield that is placed over the nipple and a plunging device that sucks milk into a bottle. You have to use your hand and force to pump, which could make the process a bit tedious.
The good thing is that you don’t have to rely on electricity or battery to make this work. This is very useful in the absence of electricity or car rides. This is beneficial to moms who don’t frequently pump.
Also, this is your best option if you want to pump for one feed a day or for an occasional break. Manual breast pumps are cheaper, smaller, lighter and quieter than their electric pump counterparts.
Once you’ve become more comfortable at pumping, you can feed your baby and pump at the other breast. There won’t be any motor noise to disturb his slumber.
Do Manual Breast Pumps Work?
Yes, this type of pump works. However, as mentioned, it can be tedious.
You have to operate it by hand and the process may take longer. Approximately 45 minutes or more.
In addition to this, you have to learn to switch hands to lighten the burden because manual pumping can be difficult. You have to use both hands. That is why it is recommended for moms who don’t frequently pump.
Although a manual pump is more challenging to use, it also comes with its own set of advantages.
For instance, in most cases, it is not as painful as electric pumps do because you can control on how hard it should suck. Also, it is quiet, cheaper, lighter, and does not include tubes, wires and other non-essentials.
How To Use Manual Breast Pump Effectively?
As mentioned, a manual breast pump is not easy to use, but there are ways to make manual pumping easier and convenient.
Here are some ways to do this.
Step 1: Read the instructions carefully
FDA recommends that the very first thing that you have to do using a breast pump is to read the instruction thoroughly. Various brands operate differently, so you have to be familiar with each pump, even if you have experienced with another brand.
Step 2: Wash your hands
Make sure that your hands are clean before assembling the breast pump. Dirty hands can spread bacteria and contaminate the pump and the milk.
So, wash your hands for at least 10-15 seconds and dry them with a clean cloth or paper towel. If you also use lotion or perfume on your breasts, take the time to wash them too before using your pump.
Step 3: Assemble your pump
Make sure to follow the instructions well and assemble the pump as instructed.
Step 4: Relax and be comfortable while pumping
Getting comfortable when pumping will help the process become easier for you. When you are relaxed the success of breast pumping increases. So, sit in a comfortable position and pump in a quiet room.
Step 5: Adjust the breast shield
Place the breast shield so your nipple is in the center of the opening. If you feel any pain or pinching, re-adjust the breast shield. You should be able to wear the shield comfortably while pumping.
Step 6: Begin Pumping
Start pumping according to the guidelines of your manual breast pump. Make sure to note how long you should pump and how much milk you should produce.
For most women, 10 to 15 minutes of pumping releases most of their milk for one session. The milk may not begin flowing immediately, so relax and be patient.
Step 7: Remove the breast shield
After you have pumped on one breast, remove the shield and move it to the other side. You should be able to remove the shield by gently using your finger between your breast and the shield to break the steal.
Step 8: Store the milk
When you have finished pumping, label the milk with the current date and time of pumping. Breast milk may be refrigerated or frozen.
Step 9: Clean the Pump
Sanitary pumping is necessary for your baby’s health. So, clean the pump after each session thoroughly. Follow the manufacturer’s guidelines to note any parts of the pump that should be immersed in water.
Step 10: Air dry
After washing, set the pieces out to air dry. In this way, your breast pump will be ready for your next session.
Is Manual Breast Pump Better Than Electric?
Manual breast pumps and electric breast pumps are designed for the same purpose, but each offers different comfort depending on how frequent you use it.
In general, a manual breast pump is a low-cost option if you will be expressing milk every now and then or if you are away from home.
However, if you are solely relying on expressed milk to breastfeed your baby, spending for a powerful hands free electric pump would be practical, quicker and easier.
So, are manual breast pumps better than electric? It depends on several factors like frequency of usage and your budget to name a few.
To help you further, I will be giving you a list where manual breast pump is better or worse than electric pump and decide for yourself, whether you want a manual or electric pump.
How Manual Breast Pump Works?
A breast pump works my mimicking the baby’s sucking pattern. In general, a baby sucks about 50 to 90 times per minute at the beginning of a feeding and slows his or her pace once let down occurs.
In a manual pump, the mother squeezes a lever or bulb to create and release suction – this is a cycling effect that triggers let down.
The plastic or glass breastshield allows a vacuum to be applied to the breast. The cone or funnel-shaped part of the breastshield, called the flange sits over the nipple and areola to create a seal. With the creation of vacuum around the nipple, air is pulled into the breastshield.
As the pump imitates a baby’s nursing rhythm milk eventually flows. The storage bags and ready-to-feed bottles directly attach to the pump collect the milk.
Electric breast pumps are more convenient to use than manual breast pumps, but there are instances when the latter is a better choice. If you want the best hand pump, the list above has it all.
Remember, you need not sweat and spend hours researching because I already did that to bring you this manual breast pump comparison review. I hope that this will help you the way, it did to others.
So, what are you waiting for? Get one of the manual pumps listed above today and enjoy the comfort and convenient it brings.